Cheapest oil drops to $5.55, propane gap narrows: Upper Valley prices, Nov. 3
By Nate Thames ·
Every Tuesday I call local dealers for their heating oil and propane prices. This week I got prices from 14 dealers for oil and 11 for propane. I’ve now been calling for six weeks, which is long enough to see some patterns, so this week’s report has a section on those too.
The short version:
Oil came down. Five dealers cut their price, by 10 to 41 cents, and only one went up. CV Oil is the new cheapest at $5.55/gal, the lowest price I’ve seen since I started calling.
Propane went up at more dealers than not, but the gap between cheapest and priciest shrank to $1.35 a gallon, from $1.81 last week. Rymes is still the cheapest, at $2.50/gal.
Steady beats lucky. Rymes has kept its oil at $5.69 for five weeks straight, and has the lowest four-week average of any dealer I’ve reached every week.
Heating oil: five dealers cut their price
Cash (COD) prices, from our phone calls to local dealers. Hover or tap a row for last week's price. Vermont average: Vermont Department of Public Service survey, week of Nov 2.
Inov8v Energy cut the most, 41 cents, to $5.79. CV Oil dropped 28 cents to $5.55, and Cota & Cota 26 cents to $5.99, the first time Cota’s price has moved since I started calling. Dead River came down 15 cents and Country Fuels a dime. Irving Oil went up a nickel. The other eight held.
The typical price, the middle of the 14, is now $5.99, down 20 cents from last week. That’s a bigger drop than the state surveys show: the Vermont average slipped just 2 cents, to $6.07 (Vermont Department of Public Service, week of Nov. 2), and New Hampshire’s a penny, to $6.03. Nine of the 14 dealers are now below the Vermont average, up from six last week.
The spread is the widest it’s been, though, because the bottom fell and the top didn’t. On a 200-gallon delivery, CV Oil at $5.55 and Gillespie Fuels & Propane at $6.41 are $172 apart.
Propane: mostly up, but closer together
Cash (COD) prices for home heating, about 800 gallons a year, from our phone calls to local dealers. Hover or tap a row for last week's price. Vermont average: Vermont Department of Public Service survey, week of Nov 2.
Eastern Propane & Oil went up 54 cents, to $3.44. Rymes went up 16 cents and Gillespie a dime; Simple Energy, Dead River and Irving each went up a nickel. Going the other way, HB Energy Solutions cut 40 cents, to $3.75, and R.E. Hinkley a dime. Cota & Cota, Inov8v and Suburban held.
With HB coming down, Irving Oil now has the highest price, at $3.85. That makes this the first week that every propane price I got was under the Vermont average ($3.94). New Hampshire’s average is $4.26.
For a house that burns about 800 gallons of propane a year, the cheapest and priciest this week work out to about $2,000 and $3,080 a year.
Six weeks of calls: what I’ve noticed
The same dealers stay cheap
Prices bounce around week to week, so one week’s cheapest dealer isn’t always the best bet. Here’s each dealer’s average oil price over the last four weeks (Oct. 13 to Nov. 3), for the nine I reached every one of those weeks, and how far their price moved in that time:
Dealer
Average, last 4 weeks
Moved by
Rymes Propane & Oil
$5.69
0¢
Eastern Propane & Oil
$5.90
10¢
Country Fuels
$6.07
20¢
Inov8v Energy
$6.07
51¢
Simple Energy
$6.14
20¢
Dead River Company
$6.16
20¢
Cota & Cota
$6.19
26¢
Irving Oil
$6.24
15¢
Suburban Propane
$6.32
11¢
Rymes has been at $5.69 every week since Oct. 6. Heatable has matched it every week since I added them on Oct. 20 (they and CV Oil, R.E. Hinkley, HB Energy and Gillespie aren’t in the table because I’ve only had them three weeks). Over the four weeks, the gap between Rymes and Suburban works out to about $125 on a 200-gallon fill.
Propane prices change more often than oil
Of 56 week-to-week oil prices I could compare, dealers held their price 26 times, almost half. Propane is different: of 41, dealers held only 10 times. The average weekly move was about a dime for oil and 15 cents for propane. If you heat with propane, a quote from a few weeks back is more likely to be out of date.
The cheapest propane keeps creeping up
Rymes: my Tuesday calls, price for a customer-owned tank. Vermont average: Vermont Department of Public Service weekly survey.
Rymes has had the cheapest or second-cheapest propane every week, but its price has gone up every week since Oct. 6: $1.94 on Oct. 6, then $2.20, $2.27, $2.34 and now $2.50. That’s 56 cents in four weeks. Over the same stretch the Vermont average rose 17 cents. Rymes is still well under the state average, but its lead over the next-cheapest dealer, Simple Energy, is down to 5 cents.
A price can swing fast
Suburban Propane’s oil went from $6.50 (the highest that week) on Sept. 29 to $5.69 (tied for the lowest) on Oct. 6, then back to $6.40 on Oct. 13. That’s the biggest swing I’ve seen. Most weeks a dealer’s oil price moves a dime or less, but it’s another reason to call before you order.
A year ago, oil was $2.58 a gallon cheaper
Vermont weekly averages: U.S. Energy Information Administration through March, then the Vermont Department of Public Service survey, which runs October through March.
In the week of Nov. 3, 2025, the Vermont average for heating oil was $3.49/gal (U.S. Energy Information Administration). This week the state survey has it at $6.07, about 74% higher. Propane is up much less: $3.49 a year ago, $3.94 now.
Heat for heat, propane is still cheaper
A gallon of oil holds more heat than a gallon of propane (about 138,500 BTU against 91,500, per the EIA). Here’s what a million BTU of heat costs at this week’s prices, before your boiler’s or furnace’s efficiency:
This week’s price
Per gallon
Per million BTU
Cheapest propane
$2.50
$27
Typical propane
$2.62
$29
Cheapest heating oil
$5.55
$40
Typical heating oil
$5.99
$43
“Typical” is the middle price of the dealers I called. Oil at $5.55 matches propane at about $3.67 a gallon.
Before you call
Ask if it’s the pay-on-time price. Nine of the 14 oil prices above are the price if you pay on time, usually within 10 days (15 at Dead River). Pay late and it’s typically a dime more; at CV Oil it’s 20 cents, so their late-pay price is $5.75.
Ask about the minimum. CV Oil needs at least 150 gallons and Rymes 200. Most dealers start at 100.
Ask if it’s for a tank you own. All the propane prices here are for a customer who owns their tank. If you lease, your price may be quite a bit higher.
All prices here are cash-on-delivery prices from my calls on Tuesday, Nov. 3, for a standard delivery. Thomson Fuels isn’t in this week’s numbers; I didn’t get a price from them. Prices change often, so confirm with the dealer before you order. See every dealer’s current price, and the prices in your town, on the price list.
Catch the next drop
We'll email you when your fuel in your ZIP code goes under your price. Signing up now also reserves the founding $19 first-year price if you decide to join the club when memberships open.
Sign up before memberships open and you'll get the founding rate: $19 for your first year, then the regular $49. Only people on the list get it. There's no limit on founding members, nothing to pay now, and no obligation to join.
Your signup helps a neighbor stay warm. We'll give $1 to LISTEN's Heating Helpers fund for each of the first 500 neighbors who sign up and tell us how they heat. How it works
We use cookies to see what's useful here and to measure our ads. Privacy policy